Bamboo Flooring vs. Laminate Flooring – Let the Battle Begin!

laminate vs bamboo flooringSonny and Cher were both talented entertainers, and yet no one got them confused with each other. Pizza and Spaghetti are two popular Italian dishes, but you would never think one was exactly the same as the other. And yet, people are constantly confusing bamboo flooring with laminate flooring. Both are practical, durable and affordable flooring options for homeowners, yet they have very obvious differences.

Properties

Often confused with a hardwood, bamboo is actually a grass and not a tree. It is far more renewable than wood, and able to regenerate in a matter of 5-7 years as opposed to 30, 50 or even 100 years in the case of hardwood trees. This makes bamboo a popular flooring choice for “green” consumers who are concerned with environmental issues.

Bamboo floor planks are manufactured by breaking down the stalks, cutting them into strips and fusing those strips together using high heat compression machines, which can give bamboo floors numerous different looks. Strand woven bamboo floors have a Janka hardness rating that is much higher than traditional wood flooring, making them extremely hard and durable.

Laminate floors are manufactured by gluing material together, but the similarity stops there. Laminate is made by adhering several layers of fiberboard (a building material made of wood fibers which have been compressed into boards), melamine (a plastic used for laminated coatings – it is made by co-polymerizing this compound with formaldehyde), and high quality photos of the type of wood the laminate is mimicking. The photos are laid on top of the fiberboard and glued into place with a protective plastic coat.  The entire product is synthetic (made of plastic) so it doesn’t have the natural warmth and feel of hardwood and bamboo flooring.

Flooring Costs

Compared to hardwood floors, the price of bamboo and laminate is more affordable to those who are on a tight budget. And, as with any building material, both options are sold within a range of prices, from very cheap to more expensive.

The real difference comes when looking at the cheaper version of both.  You can buy cheap laminate floors for around $0.99 a square foot. About the cheapest you will find bamboo is $1.79 a square foot (you’ll want to avoid that product though!). Here’s the difference: the cheap laminate is manufactured in such a way that you will have to replace the entire floor in as little as 10 years. Compare that to the cheap bamboo, which can still be sanded and refinished just like a hardwood floor, and for that extra dollar per square foot, you’re looking at floors that will last a lifetime.

Patterns and Styles

Both laminate and bamboo come in a wide selection and variety of colors and patterns. Bamboo, in particular, can take on the look of hardwood floors. This is determined by whether the bamboo stalks are lined up on their sides before gluing. If so, the planks take on a beautiful striped pattern. If the bamboo is laid flat, the result is the recognizable “knots” in the planks. Bamboo can also be boiled before the manufacturing process, which gives it a darker, caramelized color.

Both bamboo and laminate come with their own advantages and disadvantages. In general, laminate is easy to install and is one of the cheapest flooring options on the market. It can be quite hard on the feet though, and, unlike bamboo, will not last for many years as it can’t be sanded and refinished.  Laminate is also not a real hardwood product, being that it’s made of plastic, so it is not as warm underfoot and doesn’t look as natural as bamboo flooring.

Bamboo can have the exact same look as gorgeous hardwood floors and costs a fraction of the price. It’s a greener building material and can be harder and more durable than the densest woods, so it stands up to years of wear and tear. Like hardwoods though, bamboo must be maintained properly for the beauty to last for years, and hardness aside, it can still dent and scratch unless precautions are taken.

 

 

 

 



Categories: Flooring, Interior Decorating

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>